The Sell Verses Rent Decision Process
A guided property-by-property decision tool • Complete Section A before your consultation; Sections B-G are completed with Red Dot.
Before your consultation: complete Section A only. Do not try to estimate Sections B-G on your own. During research, analysis and consultation, Red Dot's property management team will work through Sections B-G with you using property-specific estimates and qualified professional input where needed. Together, we'll compare four paths: sell now, rent and hold, rent as a bridge, or stay and reassess.
Property and owner profile - Complete before consult
Basic information | Owner's answer |
Property address / community | ________________________________________ |
Occupancy / listing status | ________________________________________ |
Needed move date / reason | ________________________________________ |
Current loan type and rate | ________________________________________ |
Target decision date | ________________________________________ |
Your desired outcome in 1, 3 and 5 years | ________________________________________ |
SELL NOW analysis - Complete with Red Dot
Sale calculation | Estimate with Red Dot |
Realistic sale price (recent comparable sales / broker review) | $ ____________ |
Minus mortgage payoff and other liens | ($ ___________) |
Minus sale-related costs, concessions and closing expenses | ($ ___________) |
Minus pre-sale repair / staging / carrying costs | ($ ___________) |
Estimated net cash from sale (may be negative) | $ ____________ |
Together, ask: Would the estimated net proceeds meet your next-housing, debt, relocation or investment needs? What happens if the property takes longer to sell, receives a lower offer, or requires additional work? Confirm capital-gain tax issues with a tax professional.
RENT & HOLD cash-flow analysis - Complete with Red Dot
Rental calculation | Estimate with Red Dot |
Realistic rent actually collected (not just asking rent) | $ ____________ |
Mortgage payment (principal, interest and escrow, if included) | ($ ___________) |
HOA / condo dues and taxes / insurance not already in escrow | ($ ___________) |
Professional management and recurring operating costs | ($ ___________) |
Routine maintenance and other recurring cash costs | ($ ___________) |
Estimated monthly cash flow before nonrecurring shocks | $ ____________ |
Red Dot will help build this approximate money-in/money-out cash-flow test using property-specific estimates. It is NOT net operating income (NOI) because it includes mortgage payments. Avoid double-counting escrowed taxes or insurance; equity principal reduction is not spendable monthly cash.
Stress test - Complete with Red Dot
Stress question | Review with Red Dot |
One or two months vacant: cash needed | ____________________________ |
Turnover / leasing / cleaning and repair costs | ____________________________ |
Roof, HVAC, drainage or other capital repairs | ____________________________ |
Rental insurance or HOA restrictions verified? | Yes / No / Follow up |
Minimum liquid reserve you will maintain | $ ____________ |
If rent is lower or costs higher, will this still work? | Yes / No / Unsure |
Compare the four paths - Review together
After completing Sections B-D with Red Dot, review one decision factor at a time. Check every path that fits the owner’s needs for that factor. You may check more than one box in a row, or leave a row blank if more facts are needed. A checked box means “worth considering,” not an automatic recommendation.
Decision factor | Sell now | Rent & hold | Bridge | Stay / revisit |
Meets my equity needs | ☐ | ☐ | ☐ | ☐ |
Meets monthly cash needs | ☐ | ☐ | ☐ | ☐ |
Fits repair / vacancy risk tolerance | ☐ | ☐ | ☐ | ☐ |
Fits desired owner involvement | ☐ | ☐ | ☐ | ☐ |
Preserves needed flexibility | ☐ | ☐ | ☐ | ☐ |
Fits my timeline | ☐ | ☐ | ☐ | ☐ |
Bridge plan and exit - Define with Red Dot
Bridge control | Plan with Red Dot |
Bridge review date (for example at lease renewal) | ____________________________ |
Maximum acceptable monthly shortfall | $ ____________ |
Minimum reserve balance | $ ____________ |
Events that trigger another sale review | ____________________________ |
Lease / occupancy constraints on sale timing | ____________________________ |
Seven questions to review together before deciding
- What will I actually receive if I sell?
- What is realistic monthly rental cash flow?
- What repairs or improvements are required for either path?
- Can my reserves absorb vacancy and capital work?
- How does the choice fit my future residence and investment plans?
- Have I reviewed taxes, insurance, HOA and possible VA entitlement implications?
- Am I ready for legal and financial landlord responsibilities even with a manager?
Next step: Current leading option ____________________ | Important missing fact ____________________ | Date to decide ____________________
This worksheet supports a guided consultation; it is not intended to produce a do-it-yourself recommendation. Confirm tax, legal, financing, insurance and local rental obligations with qualified professionals. Return to the Sell vs Rent Authority Hub for the complete decision guide.




