Expanded Sell Verses Rent Comparison Worksheet

The Sell Verses Rent Decision Process

A guided property-by-property decision tool • Complete Section A before your consultation; Sections B-G are completed with Red Dot.

Before your consultation: complete Section A only. Do not try to estimate Sections B-G on your own. During research, analysis and consultation, Red Dot's property management team will work through Sections B-G with you using property-specific estimates and qualified professional input where needed. Together, we'll compare four paths: sell now, rent and hold, rent as a bridge, or stay and reassess.

Property and owner profile - Complete before consult

Basic information

Owner's answer

Property address / community

________________________________________

Occupancy / listing status

________________________________________

Needed move date / reason

________________________________________

Current loan type and rate

________________________________________

Target decision date

________________________________________

Your desired outcome in 1, 3 and 5 years

________________________________________

SELL NOW analysis - Complete with Red Dot

Sale calculation

Estimate with Red Dot

Realistic sale price (recent comparable sales / broker review)

$ ____________

Minus mortgage payoff and other liens

($ ___________)

Minus sale-related costs, concessions and closing expenses

($ ___________)

Minus pre-sale repair / staging / carrying costs

($ ___________)

Estimated net cash from sale (may be negative)

$ ____________

Together, ask: Would the estimated net proceeds meet your next-housing, debt, relocation or investment needs? What happens if the property takes longer to sell, receives a lower offer, or requires additional work? Confirm capital-gain tax issues with a tax professional.

RENT & HOLD cash-flow analysis - Complete with Red Dot

Rental calculation

Estimate with Red Dot

Realistic rent actually collected (not just asking rent)

$ ____________

Mortgage payment (principal, interest and escrow, if included)

($ ___________)

HOA / condo dues and taxes / insurance not already in escrow

($ ___________)

Professional management and recurring operating costs

($ ___________)

Routine maintenance and other recurring cash costs

($ ___________)

Estimated monthly cash flow before nonrecurring shocks

$ ____________

Red Dot will help build this approximate money-in/money-out cash-flow test using property-specific estimates. It is NOT net operating income (NOI) because it includes mortgage payments. Avoid double-counting escrowed taxes or insurance; equity principal reduction is not spendable monthly cash.

Stress test - Complete with Red Dot

Stress question

Review with Red Dot

One or two months vacant: cash needed

____________________________

Turnover / leasing / cleaning and repair costs

____________________________

Roof, HVAC, drainage or other capital repairs

____________________________

Rental insurance or HOA restrictions verified?

Yes / No / Follow up

Minimum liquid reserve you will maintain

$ ____________

If rent is lower or costs higher, will this still work?

Yes / No / Unsure

Civ 3

Compare the four paths - Review together

After completing Sections B-D with Red Dot, review one decision factor at a time. Check every path that fits the owner’s needs for that factor. You may check more than one box in a row, or leave a row blank if more facts are needed. A checked box means “worth considering,” not an automatic recommendation.

Decision factor

Sell now

Rent & hold

Bridge

Stay / revisit

Meets my equity needs

☐

☐

☐

☐

Meets monthly cash needs

☐

☐

☐

☐

Fits repair / vacancy risk tolerance

☐

☐

☐

☐

Fits desired owner involvement

☐

☐

☐

☐

Preserves needed flexibility

☐

☐

☐

☐

Fits my timeline

☐

☐

☐

☐

Bridge plan and exit - Define with Red Dot

Bridge control

Plan with Red Dot

Bridge review date (for example at lease renewal)

____________________________

Maximum acceptable monthly shortfall

$ ____________

Minimum reserve balance

$ ____________

Events that trigger another sale review

____________________________

Lease / occupancy constraints on sale timing

____________________________

Seven questions to review together before deciding

  • What will I actually receive if I sell?
  • What is realistic monthly rental cash flow?
  • What repairs or improvements are required for either path?
  • Can my reserves absorb vacancy and capital work?
  • How does the choice fit my future residence and investment plans?
  • Have I reviewed taxes, insurance, HOA and possible VA entitlement implications?
  • Am I ready for legal and financial landlord responsibilities even with a manager?

Next step: Current leading option ____________________  |  Important missing fact ____________________  |  Date to decide ____________________

This worksheet supports a guided consultation; it is not intended to produce a do-it-yourself recommendation. Confirm tax, legal, financing, insurance and local rental obligations with qualified professionals. Return to the Sell vs Rent Authority Hub for the complete decision guide.

Check out this article next

Sell vs Rent: One Page Decision Sheet

Sell vs Rent: One Page Decision Sheet

Four possible paths. Six numbers to gather. Seven questions to answer before you choose.This is a first-pass guide, not a verdict. Your property, finances, plans…

Read Article